Puddings – ButterCakery

Skip to content

Home
Order
Custom Order
Retail Shop
Weddings
Menu
About Us
Contact Us
Policies

Party Cake

Party Cake

$40.00
Vanilla Bean Cake

Vanilla Bean Cake

$30.00
Chocolate Cake

Chocolate Cake

$30.00
Strawberry Vanilla Cake

Strawberry Vanilla Cake

$70.00

Cakes

Cookies

Pudding

Cupcakes

Party Cake

Party Cake

$40.00
Vanilla Bean Cake

Vanilla Bean Cake

$30.00
Chocolate Cake

Chocolate Cake

$30.00

Custom Cakes

Custom Cupcakes

Custom Macarons

Account

Other sign in options Sign in

Orders
Profile

Account

Other sign in options Sign in

Orders
Profile

Your cart is empty

Have an account? Log in to check out faster.

Continue shopping

Puddings

Skip to results list

Availability

In stock
Out of stock

Price

$

to

$

The highest price is $36.00

Clear

1 item

Sort

Sort Best selling

Featured Most relevant Best selling Alphabetically, A-Z Alphabetically, Z-A Price, low to high Price, high to low Date, old to new Date, new to old

Column grid

Column grid

Filter

Availability

In stock
Out of stock

Price

$

to

$

The highest price is $36.00

Sort

Sort Best selling

Featured Most relevant Best selling Alphabetically, A-Z Alphabetically, Z-A Price, low to high Price, high to low Date, old to new Date, new to old

Party Size Banana Pudding

Party Size Banana Pudding

$36.00

Party Size Banana Pudding

$36.00

Real Butter, Real Ingredients, Really Beautiful Cakes

Visit Us

404 Main Street, Natchez, MS

Wednesday – Saturday 11am - 5pm Sunday 11am - 4pm

601-571-7042 Orders@buttercakery.com

Quick Links

Shop Weddings Custom Order Menu About Contact

Order Info

Standard Orders

48-hour lead time required on all standard items.

Custom Cakes

1-week minimum lead time, subject to availability.

Weddings

We recommend inquiring 3–6 months in advance to secure your date.

© 2025 Butter Cakery

Join the club

Get exclusive deals and early access to new products.

Email

© 2026 ButterCakery, Powered by Shopify

Search

Products

(1/2) Cake Deposit

(1/2) Cake Deposit

$475.00
4 Cake truffles

4 Cake truffles

$12.00
6 Cake truffles

6 Cake truffles

$16.00
Assorted Primary Color Candles

Assorted Primary Color Candles

$2.00